"Columbiana County Recorder link recorded 06222026 Shelton near Hartley if anyone can decipher what the Map refers to...
https://recordroom.cottsystems.com/columbianaoh/Guest/Search/Records/Details?IndexId=51047330"
Discussing the Marcellus and Utica Shale
John P's Discussions
Cardinal Mineral and Land Butler Township
Started this discussion. Last reply by John P Sep 14, 2023. 13 Replies 0 Likes
We were contacted several months ago by Cardinal Minerals regarding a purchase of minerals. Contract offered a respectable amount and we signed. Closing date is tomorrow and they have not notified us…Continue
Gifts Received
John P has not received any gifts yet
John P's Page
Latest Activity
LandownerJohn P replied to Jim Pollock's discussion 'Red Rock Energy' in the group Columbiana County, OH
"$3000 18%"
LandownerJohn P replied to Jim Pollock's discussion 'Red Rock Energy' in the group Columbiana County, OH
"Del Rio out of Colorado made me an offer... 31000 block of Hartley Rd. Not far from you. I wonder what they know..."
LandownerJohn P replied to John P's discussion 'Cardinal Mineral and Land Butler Township'
"They stated they made a mistake, waited until near closing to advise me of that. That was the last I heard from them."
LandownerJohn P replied to John P's discussion 'Cardinal Mineral and Land Butler Township'
"Appreciate your insight and response !!"
LandownerAndy replied to John P's discussion 'Cardinal Mineral and Land Butler Township'
"I would hold out. Once they drill Your monthly checks will definitely add up to more than what was offered . What I’ve seen checks from the first 6 months were 1,000 per acre per month. There is a good possibility they will have everything in…"
LandownerJohn P replied to John P's discussion 'Cardinal Mineral and Land Butler Township'
"They offered $1300/ acre less than what was on the contract. There were no defects on my end."
LandownerJohn P replied to John P's discussion 'Cardinal Mineral and Land Butler Township'
"It did not go through."
LandownerAndy replied to John P's discussion 'Cardinal Mineral and Land Butler Township'
"John ,
Did the deal end up not going through then?"
LandownerJoe C. replied to John P's discussion 'Cardinal Mineral and Land Butler Township'
"We get this in West Virginia as well. Mineral companies will give you big numbers without valuing the area out first and then back out of the PSA at the last minute. I had that happen in Tyler Co, WV last year. I signed a PSA, took 3 months and…"
LandownerJohn P replied to John P's discussion 'Cardinal Mineral and Land Butler Township'
"I was told our area was 2 years out for drilling... offered 7, probably good they backed out !!"
LandownerAndy replied to John P's discussion 'Cardinal Mineral and Land Butler Township'
"John,
Are currently in a well unit ? Just curious what they offered. It should have been 10,000 + if you sold your mineral rights . Considering this area is very desirable . I’ve heard of more than that offered ."
LandownerJoe C. replied to John P's discussion 'Cardinal Mineral and Land Butler Township'
"The Petroleum Landman who owns AMCO Oil and Gas knows every operator and mineral companies in the Appalachian basin. I’ve had his company help me in the past. I highly recommend him. www.amcooilgas.com. 681.209.8964, ask for Nick. "
LandownerJohn P posted a discussion
Cardinal Mineral and Land Butler Township
We were contacted several months ago by Cardinal Minerals regarding a purchase of minerals. Contract offered a respectable amount and we signed. Closing date is tomorrow and they have not notified us of anything. Failing to return calls. Has anyone else had any dealings with them ?See More
Profile Information
- What is your role?
- Landowner
- Which state(s) are you following?
- Ohio
- What shale plays do you follow?
- Marcellus
Comment Wall (1 comment)
- At 1:38am on March 18, 2014,
LandownerJames Yoder said… Hi John,
My family did sell our rights. We sold to Keystone Buckeye Energy out of Pittsburgh. Very professional, paid us on time, very smooth process. I can provide you a contact number if you'd like.
James
Top Content
Local Groups
-
Washington County, OH
160 members
-
Tioga County, PA
396 members
-
WV Land Owners
167 members
-
Beaver County, PA
239 members
-
Trumbull County, OH
305 members
-
Monongalia County, WV
76 members
-
Harrison County, WV
40 members
-
Allegheny County, PA
33 members
-
ET Rover Landowners Group
114 members
-
Bradford County, PA
505 members
Photos
© 2026 Created by Keith Mauck (Site Publisher).
Powered by
